This bug led to issues for us so it may help others to resolve it.
Currently, the AP_HAL_Linux RCInput::read(uint16_t*,uint8_t) function
only returns the first x nonzero channels. Once it hits a channel that
is set to zero, it stops and all remaining channels are returned as
zero, even if they are set. This causes discrepancies between the raw RC
input sent to the GCS and the RC input that is actually used on the
vehicle.
The fixes this issue and makes it behave exactly as it does on the
PX4_HAL code. We ran into this issue when sending rc_override messages
in which there were some channels set to zero.
0-length arrays are supported in C but forbidden in C++. GCC allows it
but clang is more strict:
../../libraries/AP_HAL_Linux/SPIDriver.cpp:75:35: fatal error: no matching constructor for initialization of 'Linux::SPIDeviceDriver [0]'
SPIDeviceDriver SPIDeviceManager::_device[0];
^
../../libraries/AP_HAL_Linux/SPIDriver.h:20:7: note: candidate constructor (the implicit move constructor) not viable: requires 1 argument, but 0 were provided
class SPIDeviceDriver : public AP_HAL::SPIDeviceDriver {
^
../../libraries/AP_HAL_Linux/SPIDriver.h:20:7: note: candidate constructor (the implicit copy constructor) not viable: requires 1 argument, but 0 were provided
../../libraries/AP_HAL_Linux/SPIDriver.h:25:5: note: candidate constructor not viable: requires 9 arguments, but 0 were provided
SPIDeviceDriver(const char *name, uint16_t bus, uint16_t subdev, enum AP_HAL::SPIDeviceType type, uint8_t mode, uint8_t bitsPerWord, int16_t cs_pin, uint32_t lowspeed, uint32_t highspeed);
^
1 error generated.
This allows us to re-use SPIDevice from SPIDeviceDriver (the
to-become-SPIDeviceProperties) while the drivers are
converted. We create a fake device by calling the temporary
SPIDeviceManager::get_device() method passing the descriptor. The
transfer and assert logic is still using the old code.
Now we can interoperate SPIDeviceDriver with the ones based in
SPIDevice since they are going to use the same semaphore and bus.
The way this code is structured is a little bit different from the
SPIDriver implementation:
- We only open the bus once, no matter how many devices we have in it
- There's a single transfer() method which uses half-duplex mode
instead of full duplex. The reason is that for all cases in the
codebase we are using half-duplex transfers using the full-duplex
API, i.e. a single SPI msg with both tx and rx buffers. This is
cumbersome because the buffers need to be of the same size and the
receive buffer using an offset of the same length as the actux data
being written. This means the high level APIs need to copy buffers
around.
If later we have uses for a real full duplex case it's just a matter
of adding another transfer_fullduplex() method or something like
this.
- The methods are implemented in the SPIDevice class instead of having
proxy methods to SPIDeviceManager as is the case of SPIDriver
Also from now on we refer to the SPIDriver objects as "descriptors"
because they have the parameters of each device in the
SPIDeviceManager::devices[] table. When SPIDeviceDriver is completely
replaced we can rename them to SPIDeviceProperties.
Save in the manager the number of devices so it can be used in other
places like the SPIDevice implementation. This is a temporary storage
while we migrate to SPIDevice.
While at it use protected rather than private.
This allows us to re-use I2CDevice from I2CDriver while the drivers are
converted. We create a fake device with addr = 0 for each I2CDriver but
we only use the register/unregister logic. The transfer logic still uses
the methods from I2CDriver in order to use the right address.
Now we can interoperate I2CDevice drivers with the ones base in
I2CDriver since they are going to use the same semaphore and bus.
The I2CDriver constructors were changed to re-use the logic in I2CDevice
(it uses a number rather than an string) and the semaphore doesn't live
outside anymore, its embedded in the fake I2CDevice, as well as the
bus's file descritor.
This is a similar function to what we have in I2CDriver, but it can
receive a nullptr to recv or send. It will create 2 i2c_msg structs to
send and receive data to/from the I2C slave.
These are very similar to their counterparts in I2CDriver. The changes
were:
- Don't use fixed buffer with PATH_MAX length: allocate the string
- Change the interface to use std::vector so we can simplify the
implementation
Use pthread's barrier so we don't keep waking up threads with possibly
higher priority during initialization phase.
This also synchronizes all of them to a single point. With the previous
approach it was possible (but unlikely) that a thread hadn't reach the
synchronization point when main thread signalize "system initialized".
Staroselskii Georgii
Rustom Jehangir
mirkix
Randy Mackay
Andrew Tridgell
Ricardo de Almeida Gonzaga
Lucas De Marchi
raspilot
Pritam Ghanghas