bpo-32236: open() emits RuntimeWarning if buffering=1 for binary mode (GH-4842)

If buffering=1 is specified for open() in binary mode, it is silently
treated as buffering=-1 (i.e., the default buffer size).
Coupled with the fact that line buffering is always supported in Python 2,
such behavior caused several issues (e.g., bpo-10344, bpo-21332).

Warn that line buffering is not supported if open() is called with
binary mode and buffering=1.

Doc/library/codecs.rst

@@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ recommended approach for working with encoded text files, this module
 provides additional utility functions and classes that allow the use of a
 wider range of codecs when working with binary files:
 
-.. function:: open(filename, mode='r', encoding=None, errors='strict', buffering=1)
+.. function:: open(filename, mode='r', encoding=None, errors='strict', buffering=-1)
 
    Open an encoded file using the given *mode* and return an instance of
    :class:`StreamReaderWriter`, providing transparent encoding/decoding.
@@ -194,8 +194,8 @@ wider range of codecs when working with binary files:
    *errors* may be given to define the error handling. It defaults to ``'strict'``
    which causes a :exc:`ValueError` to be raised in case an encoding error occurs.
 
-   *buffering* has the same meaning as for the built-in :func:`open` function.  It
-   defaults to line buffered.
+   *buffering* has the same meaning as for the built-in :func:`open` function.
+   It defaults to -1 which means that the default buffer size will be used.
 
 
 .. function:: EncodedFile(file, data_encoding, file_encoding=None, errors='strict')

Lib/_pyio.py

@@ -198,6 +198,11 @@ def open(file, mode="r", buffering=-1, encoding=None, errors=None,
         raise ValueError("binary mode doesn't take an errors argument")
     if binary and newline is not None:
         raise ValueError("binary mode doesn't take a newline argument")
+    if binary and buffering == 1:
+        import warnings
+        warnings.warn("line buffering (buffering=1) isn't supported in binary "
+                      "mode, the default buffer size will be used",
+                      RuntimeWarning, 2)
     raw = FileIO(file,
                  (creating and "x" or "") +
                  (reading and "r" or "") +

Lib/codecs.py

@@ -862,7 +862,7 @@ class StreamRecoder:
 
 ### Shortcuts
 
-def open(filename, mode='r', encoding=None, errors='strict', buffering=1):
+def open(filename, mode='r', encoding=None, errors='strict', buffering=-1):
 
     """ Open an encoded file using the given mode and return
         a wrapped version providing transparent encoding/decoding.
@@ -883,7 +883,8 @@ def open(filename, mode='r', encoding=None, errors='strict', buffering=1):
         encoding error occurs.
 
         buffering has the same meaning as for the builtin open() API.
-        It defaults to line buffered.
+        It defaults to -1 which means that the default buffer size will
+        be used.
 
         The returned wrapped file object provides an extra attribute
         .encoding which allows querying the used encoding. This

Lib/subprocess.py

@@ -743,12 +743,21 @@ class Popen(object):
 
         self._closed_child_pipe_fds = False
 
+        if self.text_mode:
+            if bufsize == 1:
+                line_buffering = True
+                # Use the default buffer size for the underlying binary streams
+                # since they don't support line buffering.
+                bufsize = -1
+            else:
+                line_buffering = False
+
         try:
             if p2cwrite != -1:
                 self.stdin = io.open(p2cwrite, 'wb', bufsize)
                 if self.text_mode:
                     self.stdin = io.TextIOWrapper(self.stdin, write_through=True,
-                            line_buffering=(bufsize == 1),
+                            line_buffering=line_buffering,
                             encoding=encoding, errors=errors)
             if c2pread != -1:
                 self.stdout = io.open(c2pread, 'rb', bufsize)

Lib/test/support/__init__.py

@@ -107,7 +107,8 @@ __all__ = [
     # threads
     "threading_setup", "threading_cleanup", "reap_threads", "start_threads",
     # miscellaneous
-    "check_warnings", "check_no_resource_warning", "EnvironmentVarGuard",
+    "check_warnings", "check_no_resource_warning", "check_no_warnings",
+    "EnvironmentVarGuard",
     "run_with_locale", "swap_item",
     "swap_attr", "Matcher", "set_memlimit", "SuppressCrashReport", "sortdict",
     "run_with_tz", "PGO", "missing_compiler_executable", "fd_count",
@@ -1252,6 +1253,30 @@ def check_warnings(*filters, **kwargs):
     return _filterwarnings(filters, quiet)
 
 
+@contextlib.contextmanager
+def check_no_warnings(testcase, message='', category=Warning, force_gc=False):
+    """Context manager to check that no warnings are emitted.
+
+    This context manager enables a given warning within its scope
+    and checks that no warnings are emitted even with that warning
+    enabled.
+
+    If force_gc is True, a garbage collection is attempted before checking
+    for warnings. This may help to catch warnings emitted when objects
+    are deleted, such as ResourceWarning.
+
+    Other keyword arguments are passed to warnings.filterwarnings().
+    """
+    with warnings.catch_warnings(record=True) as warns:
+        warnings.filterwarnings('always',
+                                message=message,
+                                category=category)
+        yield
+        if force_gc:
+            gc_collect()
+    testcase.assertEqual(warns, [])
+
+
 @contextlib.contextmanager
 def check_no_resource_warning(testcase):
     """Context manager to check that no ResourceWarning is emitted.
@@ -1266,11 +1291,8 @@ def check_no_resource_warning(testcase):
     You must remove the object which may emit ResourceWarning before
     the end of the context manager.
     """
-    with warnings.catch_warnings(record=True) as warns:
-        warnings.filterwarnings('always', category=ResourceWarning)
+    with check_no_warnings(testcase, category=ResourceWarning, force_gc=True):
         yield
-        gc_collect()
-    testcase.assertEqual(warns, [])
 
 
 class CleanImport(object):

Lib/test/test_cmd_line_script.py

@@ -169,10 +169,10 @@ class CmdLineTest(unittest.TestCase):
     @contextlib.contextmanager
     def interactive_python(self, separate_stderr=False):
         if separate_stderr:
-            p = spawn_python('-i', bufsize=1, stderr=subprocess.PIPE)
+            p = spawn_python('-i', stderr=subprocess.PIPE)
             stderr = p.stderr
         else:
-            p = spawn_python('-i', bufsize=1, stderr=subprocess.STDOUT)
+            p = spawn_python('-i', stderr=subprocess.STDOUT)
             stderr = p.stdout
         try:
             # Drain stderr until prompt

Lib/test/test_file.py

@@ -169,22 +169,33 @@ class OtherFileTests:
             f.close()
             self.fail("no error for invalid mode: %s" % bad_mode)
 
+    def _checkBufferSize(self, s):
+        try:
+            f = self.open(TESTFN, 'wb', s)
+            f.write(str(s).encode("ascii"))
+            f.close()
+            f.close()
+            f = self.open(TESTFN, 'rb', s)
+            d = int(f.read().decode("ascii"))
+            f.close()
+            f.close()
+        except OSError as msg:
+            self.fail('error setting buffer size %d: %s' % (s, str(msg)))
+        self.assertEqual(d, s)
+
     def testSetBufferSize(self):
         # make sure that explicitly setting the buffer size doesn't cause
         # misbehaviour especially with repeated close() calls
-        for s in (-1, 0, 1, 512):
-            try:
-                f = self.open(TESTFN, 'wb', s)
-                f.write(str(s).encode("ascii"))
-                f.close()
-                f.close()
-                f = self.open(TESTFN, 'rb', s)
-                d = int(f.read().decode("ascii"))
-                f.close()
-                f.close()
-            except OSError as msg:
-                self.fail('error setting buffer size %d: %s' % (s, str(msg)))
-            self.assertEqual(d, s)
+        for s in (-1, 0, 512):
+            with support.check_no_warnings(self,
+                                           message='line buffering',
+                                           category=RuntimeWarning):
+                self._checkBufferSize(s)
+
+        # test that attempts to use line buffering in binary mode cause
+        # a warning
+        with self.assertWarnsRegex(RuntimeWarning, 'line buffering'):
+            self._checkBufferSize(1)
 
     def testTruncateOnWindows(self):
         # SF bug <http://www.python.org/sf/801631>

Lib/test/test_io.py

@@ -593,7 +593,7 @@ class IOTest(unittest.TestCase):
             self.large_file_ops(f)
 
     def test_with_open(self):
-        for bufsize in (0, 1, 100):
+        for bufsize in (0, 100):
             f = None
             with self.open(support.TESTFN, "wb", bufsize) as f:
                 f.write(b"xxx")

Lib/test/test_subprocess.py

@@ -1136,7 +1136,8 @@ class ProcessTestCase(BaseTestCase):
         # line is not flushed in binary mode with bufsize=1.
         # we should get empty response
         line = b'line' + os.linesep.encode() # assume ascii-based locale
-        self._test_bufsize_equal_one(line, b'', universal_newlines=False)
+        with self.assertWarnsRegex(RuntimeWarning, 'line buffering'):
+            self._test_bufsize_equal_one(line, b'', universal_newlines=False)
 
     def test_leaking_fds_on_error(self):
         # see bug #5179: Popen leaks file descriptors to PIPEs if

Misc/NEWS.d/next/Core and Builtins/2018-09-11-23-50-40.bpo-32236.3RupnN.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+Warn that line buffering is not supported if :func:`open` is called with
+binary mode and ``buffering=1``.

Modules/_io/_iomodule.c

@@ -363,6 +363,15 @@ _io_open_impl(PyObject *module, PyObject *file, const char *mode,
         goto error;
     }
 
+    if (binary && buffering == 1) {
+        if (PyErr_WarnEx(PyExc_RuntimeWarning,
+                         "line buffering (buffering=1) isn't supported in "
+                         "binary mode, the default buffer size will be used",
+                         1) < 0) {
+           goto error;
+        }
+    }
+
     /* Create the Raw file stream */
     {
         PyObject *RawIO_class = (PyObject *)&PyFileIO_Type;