Issue #19077: tempfile.TemporaryDirectory cleanup is now most likely

successful when called during nulling out of modules during shutdown.
Misleading exception no longer raised when resource warning is emitted
during shutdown.

Lib/tempfile.py

@@ -27,11 +27,12 @@ __all__ = [
 
 # Imports.
 
+import atexit as _atexit
 import functools as _functools
 import warnings as _warnings
-import sys as _sys
 import io as _io
 import os as _os
+import shutil as _shutil
 import errno as _errno
 from random import Random as _Random
 
@@ -355,10 +356,13 @@ class _TemporaryFileCloser:
     underlying file object, without adding a __del__ method to the
     temporary file."""
 
+    # Set here since __del__ checks it
+    file = None
+    close_called = False
+
     def __init__(self, file, name, delete=True):
         self.file = file
         self.name = name
-        self.close_called = False
         self.delete = delete
 
     # NT provides delete-on-close as a primitive, so we don't need
@@ -370,14 +374,13 @@ class _TemporaryFileCloser:
         # that this must be referenced as self.unlink, because the
         # name TemporaryFileWrapper may also get None'd out before
         # __del__ is called.
-        unlink = _os.unlink
 
-        def close(self):
+        def close(self, unlink=_os.unlink):
-            if not self.close_called:
+            if not self.close_called and self.file is not None:
                 self.close_called = True
                 self.file.close()
                 if self.delete:
-                    self.unlink(self.name)
+                    unlink(self.name)
 
         # Need to ensure the file is deleted on __del__
         def __del__(self):
@@ -677,9 +680,11 @@ class TemporaryDirectory(object):
     in it are removed.
     """
 
+    # Handle mkdtemp raising an exception
+    name = None
+    _closed = False
+
     def __init__(self, suffix="", prefix=template, dir=None):
-        self._closed = False
-        self.name = None # Handle mkdtemp raising an exception
         self.name = mkdtemp(suffix, prefix, dir)
 
     def __repr__(self):
@@ -688,23 +693,24 @@ class TemporaryDirectory(object):
     def __enter__(self):
         return self.name
 
-    def cleanup(self, _warn=False):
+    def cleanup(self, _warn=False, _warnings=_warnings):
         if self.name and not self._closed:
             try:
-                self._rmtree(self.name)
+                _shutil.rmtree(self.name)
             except (TypeError, AttributeError) as ex:
-                # Issue #10188: Emit a warning on stderr
+                if "None" not in '%s' % (ex,):
-                # if the directory could not be cleaned
-                # up due to missing globals
-                if "None" not in str(ex):
                     raise
-                print("ERROR: {!r} while cleaning up {!r}".format(ex, self,),
+                self._rmtree(self.name)
-                      file=_sys.stderr)
-                return
             self._closed = True
-            if _warn:
+            if _warn and _warnings.warn:
-                self._warn("Implicitly cleaning up {!r}".format(self),
+                try:
-                           ResourceWarning)
+                    _warnings.warn("Implicitly cleaning up {!r}".format(self),
+                                   ResourceWarning)
+                except:
+                    if _is_running:
+                        raise
+                    # Don't raise an exception if modules needed for emitting
+                    # a warning are already cleaned in shutdown process.
 
     def __exit__(self, exc, value, tb):
         self.cleanup()
@@ -713,36 +719,27 @@ class TemporaryDirectory(object):
         # Issue a ResourceWarning if implicit cleanup needed
         self.cleanup(_warn=True)
 
-    # XXX (ncoghlan): The following code attempts to make
+    def _rmtree(self, path, _OSError=OSError, _sep=_os.path.sep,
-    # this class tolerant of the module nulling out process
+                _listdir=_os.listdir, _remove=_os.remove, _rmdir=_os.rmdir):
-    # that happens during CPython interpreter shutdown
-    # Alas, it doesn't actually manage it. See issue #10188
-    _listdir = staticmethod(_os.listdir)
-    _path_join = staticmethod(_os.path.join)
-    _isdir = staticmethod(_os.path.isdir)
-    _islink = staticmethod(_os.path.islink)
-    _remove = staticmethod(_os.remove)
-    _rmdir = staticmethod(_os.rmdir)
-    _os_error = OSError
-    _warn = _warnings.warn
-
-    def _rmtree(self, path):
         # Essentially a stripped down version of shutil.rmtree.  We can't
         # use globals because they may be None'ed out at shutdown.
-        for name in self._listdir(path):
+        if not isinstance(path, str):
-            fullname = self._path_join(path, name)
+            _sep = _sep.encode()
-            try:
-                isdir = self._isdir(fullname) and not self._islink(fullname)
-            except self._os_error:
-                isdir = False
-            if isdir:
-                self._rmtree(fullname)
-            else:
-                try:
-                    self._remove(fullname)
-                except self._os_error:
-                    pass
         try:
-            self._rmdir(path)
+            for name in _listdir(path):
-        except self._os_error:
+                fullname = path + _sep + name
+                try:
+                    _remove(fullname)
+                except _OSError:
+                    self._rmtree(fullname)
+            _rmdir(path)
+        except _OSError:
             pass
+
+_is_running = True
+
+def _on_shutdown():
+    global _is_running
+    _is_running = False
+
+_atexit.register(_on_shutdown)

Lib/test/test_tempfile.py

@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ import contextlib
 import weakref
 
 import unittest
-from test import support
+from test import support, script_helper
 
 
 if hasattr(os, 'stat'):
@@ -1073,7 +1073,8 @@ class TestTemporaryDirectory(BaseTestCase):
         self.nameCheck(tmp.name, dir, pre, suf)
         # Create a subdirectory and some files
         if recurse:
-            self.do_create(tmp.name, pre, suf, recurse-1)
+            d1 = self.do_create(tmp.name, pre, suf, recurse-1)
+            d1.name = None
         with open(os.path.join(tmp.name, "test.txt"), "wb") as f:
             f.write(b"Hello world!")
         return tmp
@@ -1105,7 +1106,7 @@ class TestTemporaryDirectory(BaseTestCase):
     def test_cleanup_with_symlink_to_a_directory(self):
         # cleanup() should not follow symlinks to directories (issue #12464)
         d1 = self.do_create()
-        d2 = self.do_create()
+        d2 = self.do_create(recurse=0)
 
         # Symlink d1/foo -> d2
         os.symlink(d2.name, os.path.join(d1.name, "foo"))
@@ -1135,60 +1136,49 @@ class TestTemporaryDirectory(BaseTestCase):
         finally:
             os.rmdir(dir)
 
-    @unittest.expectedFailure # See issue #10188
     def test_del_on_shutdown(self):
         # A TemporaryDirectory may be cleaned up during shutdown
-        # Make sure it works with the relevant modules nulled out
         with self.do_create() as dir:
-            d = self.do_create(dir=dir)
+            for mod in ('os', 'shutil', 'sys', 'tempfile', 'warnings'):
-            # Mimic the nulling out of modules that
+                code = """if True:
-            # occurs during system shutdown
+                    import os
-            modules = [os, os.path]
+                    import shutil
-            if has_stat:
+                    import sys
-                modules.append(stat)
+                    import tempfile
-            # Currently broken, so suppress the warning
+                    import warnings
-            # that is otherwise emitted on stdout
+
-            with support.captured_stderr() as err:
+                    tmp = tempfile.TemporaryDirectory(dir={dir!r})
-                with NulledModules(*modules):
+                    sys.stdout.buffer.write(tmp.name.encode())
-                    d.cleanup()
+
-            # Currently broken, so stop spurious exception by
+                    tmp2 = os.path.join(tmp.name, 'test_dir')
-            # indicating the object has already been closed
+                    os.mkdir(tmp2)
-            d._closed = True
+                    with open(os.path.join(tmp2, "test.txt"), "w") as f:
-            # And this assert will fail, as expected by the
+                        f.write("Hello world!")
-            # unittest decorator...
+
-            self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(d.name),
+                    {mod}.tmp = tmp
-                        "TemporaryDirectory %s exists after cleanup" % d.name)
+
+                    warnings.filterwarnings("always", category=ResourceWarning)
+                    """.format(dir=dir, mod=mod)
+                rc, out, err = script_helper.assert_python_ok("-c", code)
+                tmp_name = out.decode().strip()
+                self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(tmp_name),
+                            "TemporaryDirectory %s exists after cleanup" % tmp_name)
+                err = err.decode('utf-8', 'backslashreplace')
+                self.assertNotIn("Exception ", err)
 
     def test_warnings_on_cleanup(self):
-        # Two kinds of warning on shutdown
+        # ResourceWarning will be triggered by __del__
-        #   Issue 10888: may write to stderr if modules are nulled out
-        #   ResourceWarning will be triggered by __del__
         with self.do_create() as dir:
-            if os.sep != '\\':
+            d = self.do_create(dir=dir, recurse=3)
-                # Embed a backslash in order to make sure string escaping
+            name = d.name
-                # in the displayed error message is dealt with correctly
-                suffix = '\\check_backslash_handling'
-            else:
-                suffix = ''
-            d = self.do_create(dir=dir, suf=suffix)
-
-            #Check for the Issue 10888 message
-            modules = [os, os.path]
-            if has_stat:
-                modules.append(stat)
-            with support.captured_stderr() as err:
-                with NulledModules(*modules):
-                    d.cleanup()
-            message = err.getvalue().replace('\\\\', '\\')
-            self.assertIn("while cleaning up",  message)
-            self.assertIn(d.name,  message)
 
             # Check for the resource warning
             with support.check_warnings(('Implicitly', ResourceWarning), quiet=False):
                 warnings.filterwarnings("always", category=ResourceWarning)
-                d.__del__()
+                del d
-            self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(d.name),
+                support.gc_collect()
-                        "TemporaryDirectory %s exists after __del__" % d.name)
+            self.assertFalse(os.path.exists(name),
+                        "TemporaryDirectory %s exists after __del__" % name)
 
     def test_multiple_close(self):
         # Can be cleaned-up many times without error

Misc/NEWS

@@ -50,6 +50,11 @@ Core and Builtins
 Library
 -------
 
+- Issue #19077: tempfile.TemporaryDirectory cleanup is now most likely
+  successful when called during nulling out of modules during shutdown.
+  Misleading exception no longer raised when resource warning is emitted
+  during shutdown.
+
 - Issue #20367: Fix behavior of concurrent.futures.as_completed() for
   duplicate arguments.  Patch by Glenn Langford.