Issue #11896: Save on Close failed despite selecting "Yes" in dialog.

_tkinter.c is returning <class '_tkinter.Tcl_Obj'> sometimes.  Don't use
tkinter.messagebox.Message - use the helper functions which convert to str.

Lib/idlelib/IOBinding.py

@@ -309,17 +309,20 @@ class IOBinding:
             return "yes"
         message = "Do you want to save %s before closing?" % (
             self.filename or "this untitled document")
-        m = tkMessageBox.Message(
+        confirm = tkMessageBox.askyesnocancel(
                   title="Save On Close",
                   message=message,
-            icon=tkMessageBox.QUESTION,
+                  default=tkMessageBox.YES,
-            type=tkMessageBox.YESNOCANCEL,
                   master=self.text)
-        reply = m.show()
+        if confirm:
-        if reply == "yes":
+            reply = "yes"
             self.save(None)
             if not self.get_saved():
                 reply = "cancel"
+        elif confirm is None:
+            reply = "cancel"
+        else:
+            reply = "no"
         self.text.focus_set()
         return reply
 
@@ -328,7 +331,7 @@ class IOBinding:
             self.save_as(event)
         else:
             if self.writefile(self.filename):
-                self.set_saved(1)
+                self.set_saved(True)
                 try:
                     self.editwin.store_file_breaks()
                 except AttributeError:  # may be a PyShell
@@ -420,15 +423,12 @@ class IOBinding:
             self.text.insert("end-1c", "\n")
 
     def print_window(self, event):
-        m = tkMessageBox.Message(
+        confirm = tkMessageBox.askokcancel(
                   title="Print",
                   message="Print to Default Printer",
-            icon=tkMessageBox.QUESTION,
-            type=tkMessageBox.OKCANCEL,
                   default=tkMessageBox.OK,
                   master=self.text)
-        reply = m.show()
+        if not confirm:
-        if reply != tkMessageBox.OK:
             self.text.focus_set()
             return "break"
         tempfilename = None
@@ -444,7 +444,7 @@ class IOBinding:
                 os.unlink(tempfilename)
                 return "break"
         platform = os.name
-        printPlatform=1
+        printPlatform = True
         if platform == 'posix': #posix platform
             command = idleConf.GetOption('main','General',
                                          'print-command-posix')
@@ -452,7 +452,7 @@ class IOBinding:
         elif platform == 'nt': #win32 platform
             command = idleConf.GetOption('main','General','print-command-win')
         else: #no printing for this platform
-            printPlatform=0
+            printPlatform = False
         if printPlatform:  #we can try to print for this platform
             command = command % filename
             pipe = os.popen(command, "r")

Lib/idlelib/NEWS.txt

@@ -1,7 +1,9 @@
 What's New in IDLE 3.1.4?
 =========================
 
-*Release date: 15-May-11*
+*Release date: XX-XXX-11*
+
+- Issue #11896: Save on Close failed despite selecting "Yes" in dialog.
 
 - Issue #1028: Ctrl-space binding to show completions was causing IDLE to exit.
   Tk < 8.5 was sending invalid Unicode null; replaced with valid null.

Lib/idlelib/ScriptBinding.py

@@ -174,9 +174,9 @@ class ScriptBinding:
             if autosave and filename:
                 self.editwin.io.save(None)
             else:
-                reply = self.ask_save_dialog()
+                confirm = self.ask_save_dialog()
                 self.editwin.text.focus_set()
-                if reply == "ok":
+                if confirm:
                     self.editwin.io.save(None)
                     filename = self.editwin.io.filename
                 else:
@@ -185,13 +185,11 @@ class ScriptBinding:
 
     def ask_save_dialog(self):
         msg = "Source Must Be Saved\n" + 5*' ' + "OK to Save?"
-        mb = tkMessageBox.Message(title="Save Before Run or Check",
+        confirm = tkMessageBox.askokcancel(title="Save Before Run or Check",
                                            message=msg,
-                                  icon=tkMessageBox.QUESTION,
-                                  type=tkMessageBox.OKCANCEL,
                                            default=tkMessageBox.OK,
                                            master=self.editwin.text)
-        return mb.show()
+        return confirm
 
     def errorbox(self, title, message):
         # XXX This should really be a function of EditorWindow...