diff --git a/Tools/bgen/bgen/macsupport.py b/Tools/bgen/bgen/macsupport.py
index 89d94fe1657..4e0ab0e27d7 100644
--- a/Tools/bgen/bgen/macsupport.py
+++ b/Tools/bgen/bgen/macsupport.py
@@ -70,8 +70,7 @@ WindowRef = WindowPtr
 DialogPtr = OpaqueByValueType("DialogPtr", "DlgObj")
 DialogRef = DialogPtr
 ExistingWindowPtr = OpaqueByValueType("WindowPtr", "WinObj_WhichWindow", "BUG")
-# XXX This is incorrect: it returns a Window, not a Dialog!
-ExistingDialogPtr = OpaqueByValueType("DialogPtr", "WinObj_WhichWindow", "BUG")
+ExistingDialogPtr = OpaqueByValueType("DialogPtr", "DlgObj_WhichDialog", "BUG")
 
 # NULL pointer passed in as optional storage -- not present in Python version
 NullStorage = FakeType("(void *)0")